Skip to content
Trademark Valet

Decisions · What the Board weigheddu Pont factor

How related the goods or services areFactor 2: Relatedness of the goods or services

In 37 of the 38 records in this library that list what the Board weighed, the Board made a finding on how related the goods or services are. A finding may be neutral, favor one side, or decide the outcome; each row shows its effect and what the Board found. Read the guide to this question →

37 of the 38 records in this library that code du Pont factors carry a finding on this factor. A finding may be neutral, weigh for or against confusion, or drive the result; each row shows the coded weight and what the Board found. Read the guide to this factor →

By industry
By what the Board weighedBy du Pont factor · showing how related the goods or services arefactor 2
By type of caseBy posture
DecisionResultEffectWeightWhat the Board found
In re Lasertec Corporation
2026 · GALOIS
Refusal upheldRefusal affirmedWeighed heavilySignificantWafer inspection equipment and cameras/scanners were found complementary — used together in semiconductor manufacturing — with Lasertec's own website showing its systems incorporate cameras and scanners.
In re Robert Sulic
2026 · BLACK SWAN
Proceedings decided together: 79375327, 79375609
Refusal upheldRefusal affirmedWeighed heavilySignificantVodka and wine were found related: they mix together in cocktails, some vodka is distilled from wine, over a dozen producers sell both under one name, and 18 registrations cover both.
In re Jason Jimenez
2025 · GASPER ROOFING (standard characters; ROOFING disclaimed…
Refusal overturnedRefusal reversedFavored the applicantFavored ApplicantThe sole service identified in the cited registration, "roofing services," is identical to the "roofing services" identified in the application and encompasses each specific roofing service listed in the application (roofing consultation, contracting, installation, maintenance, repair, etc.).
In re Coventya
2025 · FINIGARD
Refusal upheldRefusal affirmedWeighed heavilySignificantThe goods overlap and are legally identical in part because the cited registration covers coatings for 'other metal surfaces,' not just HVAC equipment; this factor weighed heavily toward confusion.
In re WeGrow Germany GmbH
2025 · WeGrow (stylized with leaf design)
Refusal upheld for the Class 31 goodsRefusal affirmed for the Class 31 goodsDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalLiving trees and plants are complementary to fertilizers, which promote plant growth, and nurseries sell both.
Major League Baseball Players Association v. Michael P. Chisena
2023 · HERE COMES THE JUDGE (standard characters, Serial No…
Proceedings decided together: 91240180, 91242556
The Board sustained the MLBPA's opposition and refused registration of Michael Chisena's…Decided the outcomeDispositiveApplicant's clothing is identical in part (t-shirts, shirts, sweatshirts, jerseys, caps) and otherwise complementary to the licensed apparel; the other 'key' factor.
Major League Baseball Players Association and Aaron Judge v. Michael P. Chisena
2023 · Design mark: a gavel and the scales of justice, each end…
The Board sustained the MLBPA's and Aaron Judge's joint opposition and refused…Decided the outcomeDispositiveApplicant's clothing is identical in part (t-shirts, shirts, sweatshirts, jerseys, caps) and otherwise complementary to the licensed apparel; the other 'key' factor.
Made in Nature, LLC v. Pharmavite LLC
2022 · NATURE MADE (standard characters)
Proceedings decided together: 91223352, 91223683, 91227387
The Board sustained Made in Nature's opposition and refused registration of Pharmavite's…Decided the outcomeDispositiveGoods identical in part for the Class 29 and 30 applications and related for all three, per the identifications, 31 relevant third-party registrations, 138 retailer websites and both parties' testimony.
In re Guild Mortgage Company
2020 · GUILD MORTGAGE COMPANY and design (three lines above IL)
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldFavored the refusalFavored RefusalMortgage banking and investment advisory services are related Class 36 financial services, with third-party registrations showing the same entities offering both.
In re Country Oven, Inc.
2019 · COUNTRY OVEN
The Board affirmed refusal of the identical mark COUNTRY OVEN for retail and custom…Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalBread buns and retail bakery services are related — bakeries commonly sell their own baked goods.
In re American Cruise Lines, Inc.
2018 · AMERICAN CONSTELLATION
The Board allowed AMERICAN CONSTELLATION to proceed to registration for cruise ship…Favored the refusalFavored RefusalThe cruise ship services are identical, weighing in favor of confusion.
In re FabFitFun, Inc.
2018 · I'M SMOKING HOT
The Board reversed a refusal to register I'M SMOKING HOT for cosmetics and personal care…Favored the refusalFavored RefusalThe cosmetics are identical in part.
In re i.am.symbolic, llc
2018 · #WILLPOWER
The Board refused registration of #WILLPOWER, the clothing mark of will.i.am's company…Decided the outcomeDispositiveThe application's jackets and pants are identical to the registrant's, and many other listed items (shirts, shoes, headwear, sports clothing) legally overlap with the registrant's hats, jackets, pants, shirts, and shoes.
In re I-Coat Company, LLC
2018 · INDIGO (and variants)
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalBoth applicant's optical corrective lenses and cited goods (spectacles, frames, lenses, glasses for sport, ski glasses, sunglasses) are in Class 9 optical goods. Goods are related and complement each other.
In re Inn at St. John's, LLC
2018 · 5IVE STEAKHOUSE and design (the wording "5ive" in stylized…
The Board found 5IVE STEAKHOUSE (with a fork-and-knife design) for restaurant and bar…Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThe restaurant and bar services are identical.
In re FCA US LLC
2018 · MOAB
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldFavored the refusalFavored RefusalMotor vehicles and parts are related to automotive conversion services, which sell specialty parts and install them.
In re Aquitaine Wine USA, LLC
2018 · LAROQUE Cité de Carcassonne and design (word mark with…
The Board refused to register a French winery's LAROQUE wine label showing a house and…Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalBoth identifications are French wine, and the appellation limitations do not distinguish the goods.
In re Solid State Design Inc.
2018 · populace (stylized, with silhouette of a person's head…
The Board upheld the refusal to register a stylized "populace" mark with a…Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThe software identifications are legally identical in part.
In re USA Warriors Ice Hockey Program, Inc.
2017 · USA WARRIORS ICE HOCKEY NONE TOUGHER and design [The mark…
Registration refusedRegistration refusedFavored the refusalFavored RefusalThe applicant's disabled-veteran hockey programs were treated as falling within the registrant's broader, unrestricted hockey services, which the applicant did not dispute.
In re Integrated Embedded (d/b/a Barr Group)
2016 · BARR GROUP (standard characters; GROUP disclaimed)
The USPTO's refusal to register the name BARR GROUP for IT training, engineering, and…Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThe registrant's engineering services encompass the applicant's more narrowly identified engineering services.
In re Morinaga Nyugyo Kabushiki Kaisha
2016 · MT. RAINIER THE MOUNTAIN OF SEATTLE ESPRESSO & MILK and…
The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board reached a split result for the MT. RAINIER THE…Favored the refusalFavored RefusalEspresso-and-milk beverages are strongly related to coffee.
In re Fat Boys Water Sports LLC
2016 · HOUSEBOAT BLOB (standard characters; BLOB disclaimed)
Refusal upheld on both groundsRefusal affirmed on both groundsDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalApplicant's identification (inflatable float mattresses/pads from which a user is launched into the air and onto water) was compared to Registrant's more specific identification (giant inflatable floating air bags of PVC reinforced vinyl for camps/outdoor recreation businesses, placed in bodies of water so patrons can jump from a platform and be launched off into the water).
In re Mr. Recipe, LLC
2016 · JAWS
Proceedings decided together: 86040643, 86040656
Refusals upheld for both applicationsRefusals affirmed for both applicationsFavored the refusalFavored RefusalStreaming a cooking-focused internet channel is related to motion-picture video recordings.
In re Bay State Brewing Company, Inc.
2016 · TIME TRAVELER BLONDE (standard characters, BLONDE…
Refusal upheldRefusal affirmedDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThe Board found the goods identical in part because "beer" appears in both identifications, and found the cited registration's additional goods "ale" and "lager" to be types of beer based on an unrebutted Wikipedia entry describing ale as a beer made by warm fermentation..
In re i.am.symbolic, llc
2015 · I AM
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThird-party registrations and retailer websites showed cosmetics/personal care products and perfume are commonly sold under one mark, and the registrant herself sold body butter and body wash under I AM, so the goods are related — and the 'associated with will.i.am' language did not change that.
In re C. H. Hanson Company
2015 · C.H. HANSON
Refusal upheldRefusal affirmedDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalThe registered 'wrenches' identification was read to include ordinary wrenches, and internet listings plus third-party registrations showed the same brands sell both sides' tools, so the goods are related.
In re Allegiance Staffing
2015 · ALLEGIANCE STAFFING
Refusal overturnedRefusal reversedFavored the refusalFavored RefusalThe staffing services are legally identical.
In re Aquamar, Inc.
2015 · MARAZUL
The Board refused registration of MARAZUL for frozen and fresh processed fish, seafood…Decided the outcomeDispositiveBoth identifications cover frozen fish, and the registration's non-live fish encompasses Aquamar's fresh processed fish, so the goods are legally identical in part.
In re Hughes Furniture Industries, Inc.
2015 · HUGHES FURNITURE (and design with H logo and MOTION EAZE…
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldFavored the refusalFavored RefusalThe applicant's unrestricted 'furniture' necessarily encompasses the registrant's residential and commercial furniture.
In re House Beer, LLC
2015 · HOUSE BEER (standard characters, BEER disclaimed)
Refusal upheldRefusal upheldFavored the refusalFavored RefusalBeer and retail store services featuring beer are commonplace related goods and services familiar to consumers.
In re Thor Tech, Inc.
2015 · TERRAIN (standard characters)
Refusal overturnedRefusal reversedDecided the outcome, for the applicantDispositive — Favored ApplicantTrucks and towable RV trailers are noncompetitive, differ completely in utility, and share nothing essential.
In re Covalinski
2014 · REDNECK RACEGIRL and design (two large Rs with checkerboard…
Refusal overturnedRefusal reversedFavored the refusalFavored RefusalThe athletic apparel is in-part legally identical to the registrant's clothing.

Counts describe this curated library as of its coding date, not all TTAB decisions. Consolidated proceedings are counted once per application; proceedings decided together with the same finding share one row.