In re Robert Sulic
Serial No. 79375327 · Decided 2026-01-07 · Section 2(d) Ex Parte Appeal
Decided 2026-01-07 · Appeal of a refusal for likely confusion
Read the opinion on TTABVUE, the Board's docket · About this summary
What happened
Refusal affirmed — the Board found Robert Sulic’s BLACK SWAN vodka mark identical to the registered BLACK SWAN mark for wines, and because vodka and wine are related drinks sold through overlapping channels, confusion is likely and the mark cannot register.
The marks
Applicant
BLACK SWAN
Vodka (Class 33)
Cited registration
BLACK SWAN
Wines (Class 33)
How the marks compared
| Dimension | Finding | What the Board said |
|---|---|---|
| soundsound | Similar | The word mark is identical to the registered mark. |
| lookappearance | Similar | Identical standard-character wording. |
| meaningmeaning | Similar | Identical arbitrary phrase for the goods. |
| overall impressioncommercial impression | Similar | Identical marks convey the same impression. |
Similar
What the Board weigheddu Pont factors that bore on the outcome
| # | QuestionFactor | EffectWeight | What the Board found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | How similar the marks areSimilarity of the marks | Weighed heavilySignificant | BLACK SWAN is identical to the registered mark (word application) and the label version’s swan drawing only reinforces those dominant words. |
| 2 | How related the goods or services areRelatedness of the goods or services | Weighed heavilySignificant | Vodka and wine were found related: they mix together in cocktails, some vodka is distilled from wine, over a dozen producers sell both under one name, and 18 registrations cover both. |
| 3 | Where the goods are sold, and to whomSimilarity of trade channels | Weighed heavilySignificant | Producers' websites sell both products together, showing at least limited overlap in where consumers buy them. |
Why this decision is significant
Rich three-route template for proving (or attacking) relatedness of different alcoholic beverages — cocktail complementarity, same-source producers, and use-based third-party registrations — with the old White Rock vodka/wine no-relatedness holding distinguished as record-specific. Also a clean Herbko application: a design depicting the words reinforces rather than distinguishes.
Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.
Why lawyers cite this decision
Rich three-route template for proving (or attacking) relatedness of different alcoholic beverages — cocktail complementarity, same-source producers, and use-based third-party registrations — with the old White Rock vodka/wine no-relatedness holding distinguished as record-specific. Also a clean Herbko application: a design depicting the words reinforces rather than distinguishes.
Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.
Related decisions
The original record
Read the opinion and every filing on the Board's own docket. The summary above is our paraphrase, not a quotation from the opinion. The opinion is the authority.