Made in Nature, LLC v. Pharmavite LLC
Opposition No. 91227387 · Decided 2022-06-15 · Opposition
Decided 2022-06-15 · Challenge to an application
Read the opinion on TTABVUE, the Board's docket · About this summary
What happened
The Board sustained Made in Nature’s opposition and refused registration of Pharmavite’s NATURE MADE mark for Class 32 beverages such as nutritional-supplement energy drinks, vitamin and flavored waters, smoothies and herbal juices, finding the mark highly similar to Made in Nature’s MADE IN NATURE marks for fresh, dried and chocolate-covered fruits and vegetables — the same words simply transposed — and the beverages related to Made in Nature’s foods through third-party registrations, shared retail websites and overlapping trade channels.
The marks
Applicant
NATURE MADE (standard characters)
Beauty beverages (energy drinks containing nutritional supplements), tea-flavored beverages, vitamin waters, bottled and flavored waters, smoothies, energy drinks, soy-based beverages, and herbal juices (Class 32; Application Serial No. 85862776, intent to use)
Opposer's mark
MADE IN NATURE (standard characters and design forms); ORGANIC MADE IN NATURE (13 registrations, plus common-law MADE IN NATURE rights)
Fresh, dried, dehydrated and prepared fruits and vegetables, dried fruit-based snacks and fruit-based snack foods, and chocolate covered fruit (Classes 29, 30, 31); common-law dried fruits since as early as 1996
How the marks compared
| Dimension | Finding | What the Board said |
|---|---|---|
| soundsound | Similar | Same two words MADE and NATURE spoken in reverse order, dropping only the preposition ‘in’ |
| lookappearance | Similar | Reverse combination of the same words; standard-character application could appear in the same font, size, color and stylization as the prior marks |
| meaningmeaning | Similar | Both phrases mean created by or from nature, focusing on the same natural-origin characteristic of the goods |
| overall impressioncommercial impression | Similar | Transposed marks convey substantially the same commercial impression under the DIET-RITE/RITE DIET line of cases |
The Board found the marks similar in appearance, sound, meaning and commercial impression — indeed ‘highly similar’ — because NATURE MADE is simply MADE IN NATURE transposed.
What the Board weigheddu Pont factors that bore on the outcome
| # | QuestionFactor | EffectWeight | What the Board found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | How similar the marks areSimilarity of the marks | Decided the outcomeDispositive | NATURE MADE is a reverse combination/transposition of MADE IN NATURE conveying the same meaning; found highly similar. |
| 2 | How related the goods or services areRelatedness of the goods or services | Decided the outcomeDispositive | Goods identical in part for the Class 29 and 30 applications and related for all three, per the identifications, 31 relevant third-party registrations, 138 retailer websites and both parties' testimony. |
| 3 | Where the goods are sold, and to whomSimilarity of trade channels | Favored the opposerFavored Opposer | Unrestricted identifications; channels and ordinary general-public purchasers presumed identical or shown to overlap. |
| 4 | How carefully buyers shopConditions of sale and buyer sophistication | Favored the opposerFavored Opposer | Low-cost groceries bought quickly and often on impulse; least sophisticated potential purchaser standard applied. |
| 5 | How well known the earlier mark isFame of the prior mark | NeutralNeutral | Fame not proven; marks conceptually weak (highly suggestive) but registered and of moderate commercial strength. |
| 6 | Similar marks already in useNumber and nature of similar marks in use | Favored the applicantFavored Applicant | Admissible third-party registrations showed the individual terms NATURE and MADE weak, making the marks highly suggestive — but weak marks are still protected. |
| 7 | Whether anyone was actually confusedNature and extent of actual confusion | NeutralNeutral | No actual confusion, but the intent-to-use goods have essentially not been sold, so there was no reasonable opportunity for confusion. |
| 12 | How much confusion could resultExtent of potential confusion | Favored the opposerFavored Opposer | Potential confusion found substantial, not de minimis. |
Why this decision is significant
Precedential consolidated opposition holding transposed marks (MADE IN NATURE vs. NATURE MADE) highly similar and refusing a famous supplement brand’s food/beverage extension; also instructive on mass third-party-registration weakness evidence (975 filed, ~90 relevant), fame versus moderate commercial strength, neutral actual-confusion analysis for intent-to-use goods, and untimely Morehouse defenses, with pointed practice guidance on record management.
Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.
Why lawyers cite this decision
Precedential consolidated opposition holding transposed marks (MADE IN NATURE vs. NATURE MADE) highly similar and refusing a famous supplement brand’s food/beverage extension; also instructive on mass third-party-registration weakness evidence (975 filed, ~90 relevant), fame versus moderate commercial strength, neutral actual-confusion analysis for intent-to-use goods, and untimely Morehouse defenses, with pointed practice guidance on record management.
Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.
Related decisions
The original record
Read the opinion and every filing on the Board's own docket. The summary above is our paraphrase, not a quotation from the opinion. The opinion is the authority.