Skip to content
Trademark Valet

Decisions · 86802467, 86802618, and 86802733

PrecedentialResearch: NotableNo later change on its docket

In re I-Coat Company, LLC

Serial Nos. 86802467, 86802618, and 86802733 · Decided 2018-06-07 · Section 2(d) Ex Parte Appeal

Decided 2018-06-07 · Appeal of a refusal for likely confusion

Read the opinion on TTABVUE, the Board's docket  · About this summary

What happened

Refusal upheld — I-Coat’s INDIGO marks (word and two design versions) for corrective lenses were found too similar to the registered INDIGOSNOW and INDIGO marks for eyewear, blocking all three applications.

The marks

Applicant

INDIGO (and variants)

optical lenses, namely corrective lenses sold through eye care professionals

Cited registration

INDIGOSNOW / INDIGO

spectacles, spectacle cases, spectacle lenses, spectacle settings, spectacle frames, glasses for sport, ski glasses, ski goggles, sunglasses

How the marks compared

DimensionFindingWhat the Board said
soundsoundSimilarINDIGO is the dominant element in all marks; SNOW is a weak addition
lookappearanceSimilarINDIGO dominates visual impression despite design elements in applicant’s marks
overall impressioncommercial impressionSimilarINDIGO is the dominant commercial impression across all marks

Similar — INDIGO is the dominant element in both applicant’s and registrant’s marks for related optical goods.

What the Board weigheddu Pont factors that bore on the outcome

#QuestionFactorEffectWeightWhat the Board found
1How similar the marks areSimilarity of the marksDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalMarks are identical or more similar than dissimilar. INDIGO in standard characters is identical to INDIGO in cited mark. Applicant’s design variants (AR design and color design) are more similar than dissimilar to…
2How related the goods or services areRelatedness of the goods or servicesDecided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalBoth applicant’s optical corrective lenses and cited goods (spectacles, frames, lenses, glasses for sport, ski glasses, sunglasses) are in Class 9 optical goods. Goods are related and complement each other.
4How carefully buyers shopConditions of sale and buyer sophistication
corrected from 3. Trade Channels and Conditions of Purchase
Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalAlthough applicant limited goods to “through eye care professionals,” cited marks are registered without such limitations. Internet evidence shows both corrective lenses and sunglasses sold on same websites. Must…
4How carefully buyers shopConditions of sale and buyer sophistication
corrected from 3. Trade Channels and Conditions of Purchase
NeutralNeutralBoth goods target consumers seeking vision correction or enhancement/protection. Customers are same or overlapping demographic.
4How carefully buyers shopConditions of sale and buyer sophistication
corrected from 3. Trade Channels and Conditions of Purchase
NeutralNeutralNo evidence of purchaser sophistication beyond goods nature. Even careful, sophisticated consumers likely to believe identical/similar marks point to common source when goods are related.
7Whether anyone was actually confusedNature and extent of actual confusion
corrected from 6. Actual Confusion
NeutralNeutralNo discussion of actual confusion evidence in decision.
7Whether anyone was actually confusedNature and extent of actual confusion
corrected from 6. Actual Confusion
Decided the outcome, for the refusalDispositive — Favored RefusalTotality of circumstances including identical marks, related goods, and common trade channels leads to finding of likelihood of confusion.

5 factor labels were renumbered to match the canonical du Pont list. The extraction's original label is shown beneath.

Why this decision is significant

Precedential consolidated 2(d) affirmance refusing INDIGO in standard-character and two design forms over INDIGOSNOW and INDIGO for related optical goods. Also the decision announcing that internet evidence must include the URL and access date to be considered — a procedural rule of ongoing significance.

Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.

Why lawyers cite this decision

Precedential consolidated 2(d) affirmance refusing INDIGO in standard-character and two design forms over INDIGOSNOW and INDIGO for related optical goods. Also the decision announcing that internet evidence must include the URL and access date to be considered — a procedural rule of ongoing significance.

Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.

Related decisions

The original record

Read the opinion and every filing on the Board's own docket. The summary above is our paraphrase, not a quotation from the opinion. The opinion is the authority.

Open this case on TTABVUE, the Board's docket 


← Back to the library