Skip to content
Trademark Valet

Decisions · Opposition No. 91243244

PrecedentialResearch: NotableNo later change on its docket

Major League Baseball Players Association and Aaron Judge v. Michael P. Chisena

Opposition No. 91243244 · Decided 2023-04-12 · Opposition

Decided 2023-04-12 · Challenge to an application

Read the opinion on TTABVUE, the Board's docket  · About this summary

What happened

The Board sustained the MLBPA’s and Aaron Judge’s joint opposition and refused registration of Michael Chisena’s gavel-and-scales-of-justice-over-baseball-field design mark for t-shirts and other clothing, finding licensees sold apparel with judicial symbols referencing Judge (including scales-of-justice-over-baseball designs) months before Chisena’s October 12, 2017 intent-to-use filing, and that the design would be confused with Judge-authorized merchandise.

The marks

Applicant

Design mark: a gavel and the scales of justice, each end supporting a baseball, superimposed over the outline of a baseball field (Serial No. 87643089)

Clothing, namely, t-shirts, shirts, shorts, pants, sweatshirts, sweatpants, jackets, jerseys, athletic uniforms, and caps (Class 25; intent-to-use)

Opposer's mark

Common-law judicial symbols and terminology -- gavel, courthouse and scales-of-justice designs with JUDGE, HERE COMES THE JUDGE and ALL RISE -- used on licensed Aaron Judge apparel

T-shirts, baseball caps and other athletic apparel sold by MLBPA-approved licensees bearing Aaron Judge-related judicial phrases and symbols (common-law use; no registration pleaded)

How the marks compared

DimensionFindingWhat the Board said
lookappearanceSimilarThe design’s judicial imagery against a baseball diamond mirrors the licensed designs: scales of justice tilt toward right field (Judge’s position) and a gavel — imagery frequently substituted for a bat in Judge’s hands — strikes a baseball; depiction possible in Yankees navy and white.
meaningmeaningSimilarJudicial phrasing and imagery understood as a play on Aaron Judge’s judicial-sounding surname — the same connotation carried by Opposers' licensed slogans and symbols.
overall impressioncommercial impressionSimilarIn the context of sports-fan purchasers and unrestricted trade channels, the Board found the commercial impression ‘unmistakable: it refers to Aaron Judge,’ conveying that the goods emanate from an MLBPA licensee sponsored or approved by Judge.

The marks are so similar in commercial impression that persons encountering them would likely assume a connection between the parties; the first DuPont factor weighed heavily in favor of confusion.

What the Board weigheddu Pont factors that bore on the outcome

#QuestionFactorEffectWeightWhat the Board found
1How similar the marks areSimilarity of the marksDecided the outcomeDispositiveCommercial impression unmistakably refers to Aaron Judge; weighed heavily in favor of confusion, one of the two ‘key’ factors resolving the case.
2How related the goods or services areRelatedness of the goods or servicesDecided the outcomeDispositiveApplicant’s clothing is identical in part (t-shirts, shirts, sweatshirts, jerseys, caps) and otherwise complementary to the licensed apparel; the other ‘key’ factor.
3Where the goods are sold, and to whomSimilarity of trade channelsFavored the opposerFavored OpposerOverlapping goods create presumed overlapping channels — sports venues and sporting goods stores serving baseball fans.
4How carefully buyers shopConditions of sale and buyer sophisticationFavored the opposerFavored OpposerInexpensive casual apparel bought on impulse without great care, increasing confusion.
13Other relevant factsAny other established fact probative of the effect of useNeutralNeutralUntimely reply-brief bad-faith argument not weighed, though the record negated Applicant’s good-faith protestations.

Why this decision is significant

Precedential decision holding that fan- and media-coined celebrity slogans used on union-licensed merchandise are common-law trademarks identifying the athlete as a secondary source, and mapping how personality-merchandising opposers prove priority against opportunistic ITU filers. Leading modern authority on failure-to-function/ornamentation defenses in athlete-merchandise disputes.

Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.

Why lawyers cite this decision

Precedential decision holding that fan- and media-coined celebrity slogans used on union-licensed merchandise are common-law trademarks identifying the athlete as a secondary source, and mapping how personality-merchandising opposers prove priority against opportunistic ITU filers. Leading modern authority on failure-to-function/ornamentation defenses in athlete-merchandise disputes.

Research significance is Trademark Valet's editorial rating of how useful a decision is to practitioners. It is not a statement of precedential weight — that is the separate Precedential field, which comes from the Board.

Related decisions

The original record

Read the opinion and every filing on the Board's own docket. The summary above is our paraphrase, not a quotation from the opinion. The opinion is the authority.

Open this case on TTABVUE, the Board's docket 


← Back to the library